Save your search and get notified when new inventory arrives.
Contact seller
Customize your budget
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
About your privacy: Cars.com is asking for your ZIP and credit rating because it helps us to make an educated guess at your sales tax and loan interest. These two factors can greatly change your monthly payment.
Used
2016 Subaru Legacy
for sale
near
New York, NY
- Down Payment
- $0
- Net trade-in value
- $0
- Months
- 72
- APR
- 7.0%
- Sales tax
- 0.0%
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.






Used
2016 Subaru Legacy Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Our experience at Liberty Subaru was, from start to
Our experience at Liberty Subaru was, from start to finish, quite fine. Our sales consultant, John Clarke was excellent, indeed. He provided thorough explanations of the various features of our new Forester. Thorough, clear and patient--never rushed or pushy. He didn't just explain the car's features; he took us to the car itself and demonstrated some of these features. For example, the connection to the navigation system. This was reassuring, given all the new technology in the 2025 Forester. It is clear that he is very knowledgeable about the car and because of that knowledge, seems to genuinely like it. A lot! He has an even and warm personality. It was such a pleasure to have him introduce us to our new car!
Third time is the Charm!
My third Subaru and like the others is attractive and roomy enough to fit 5. I've hauled 8ft boards inside with the doors/trunk closed (only an Outback would hold more). The (now sadly discontinued) 6-cyl engine has about 51000 miles now and is smooth and sounds better than a four. Fuel economy is decent and, on regular gas, averages in the low 20s. It has all the 'nannies' which make driving safer for me. I just love looking at my car which is important to me. This one's a keeper!






Used
2016 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Have been going to Paramus Honda for 25 years now.
Have been going to Paramus Honda for 25 years now. Only go back to the best. Manny my sales rep is the best. Very understanding and always makes sure I leave happy with my new car.
Bang for Your Buck - Preowned Subaru Legacy!
This car met and exceeded my expectations. I previously owned a 2012 Subaru Legacy. My '16 is what I wished my '12 was & more!






Used
2016 Subaru Legacy Premium
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Very friendly experience, greatly appreciated the
Very friendly experience, greatly appreciated the knowledge that was shared. Will definitely recommend this business
Most reliable car I've ever owned. Dependable!
My third Subaru and like the others is attractive, roomy, of ample size to fit 4 or 5. I've hauled 8ft pipes inside with the doors/trunk closed (only an Outback would hold more). The (now sadly discontinued) 6-cyl engine sounds better than the four, and fuel economy (regular gas) is in the low 20s on average. It has all the 'nannies' which make driving safer for me. I just love looking at my car which is important for me.






Used
2016 Subaru Legacy 3.6R Limited
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
Had a great time today buying my dream Car !
Had a great time today buying my dream Car ! THANK YOU Jose M . I loved working with you & I’ll be sending all my friends and family ! Thank you auto spot and thank you Mario .
Great Car! Amazing Safety feautres.
We got the 2.5 Premium version of this car. The safety feautres such as eyesight assist, lane change "alarms" and "smart" cruise control is amazing. These features are so awesome, it caused my husband to purchase a Legacy as well!






Used
2016 Subaru Legacy Limited
Vehicle information
Features
Reviews
2003 Wrangler
We drove almost two hours to this dealership to look at a 2003 Wrangler that they had. The trip was well worth it. Mark and his team were pleasant and accommodating, and made what can sometimes be a grueling process very quick, easy, and hassle-free. The next time we are in the market for a pre-owned car, I will not hesitate to check out their inventory and make the trip again.
An amazing value, very reliable driving in snow
Purchased a used 2016 Subaru Legacy Premium 2.5i Premium with just under 40k miles on it. I’ve been driving this car for about 5 months now and so far can’t say anything but great things about it. I live in Chicagoland so it is a perfect car for Chicago’s weather.
-
Prev - 1
-
Next
Subaru Legacy prices by year
Model year | Prices from | Deals |
---|---|---|
2025 Subaru Legacy | $25,286 | 4 Good deals |
2022 Subaru Legacy | $18,250 | 15 Great deals |
About the 2016 Subaru Legacy
2.5i shown (base trim).
- Seating
- 5
- Door count
- 4
- Drivetrain
- All-wheel drive
- Combined MPG
- 30
- Transmission
- CVT Transmission
- Engine
- 175.0-hp, 2.5-liter, 4 Cylinder Engine (Gasoline Fuel)

How much does the 2016 Subaru Legacy cost?
The 2016 Subaru Legacy price depends on several factors, including the trim level, optional features, mileage, vehicle history and location. The nationwide average price for a 2016 Legacy is $13,056, with pricing starting at $5,295.
What is the MPG of the 2016 Subaru Legacy?
The 2016 Subaru Legacy offers up to 26 MPG in city driving and 36 MPG on the highway for a combined rating of 30 MPG.
These figures are based on EPA mileage ratings and are for comparison purposes only. The actual mileage will vary depending on the selected vehicle trim, driving conditions, driving habits, vehicle maintenance, and other factors.
What are some similar vehicles and competitors of the 2016 Subaru Legacy?
The 2016 Subaru Legacy compares to and/or competes against the following vehicles:
Is the 2016 Subaru Legacy reliable?
The 2016 Subaru Legacy has an average reliability rating of 4.7 out of 5 according to Cars.com consumers. Find real-world reliability insights within consumer reviews from 2016 Legacy owners.
Is the 2016 Subaru Legacy a good sedan?
Below are the Cars.com consumer ratings for the 2016 Subaru Legacy.
- Comfort 4.7
- Interior 4.5
- Performance 4.4
- Value 4.6
- Exterior 4.5
- Reliability 4.7
92% of drivers recommend this car
- Comfort 4.7
- Interior 4.5
- Performance 4.4
- Value 4.6
- Exterior 4.5
- Reliability 4.7
2.5i (1 style)
Style |
---|
4dr Sdn 2.5i |
Inventory price |
Starting at $21,745 |
Combined MPG |
30 |
Engine |
175.0-hp, 2.5-liter, 4 Cylinder Engine (Gasoline Fuel) |
2.5i Limited (1 style)
Style |
---|
4dr Sdn 2.5i Limited |
Inventory price |
Starting at $26,845 |
Combined MPG |
30 |
Engine |
175.0-hp, 2.5-liter, 4 Cylinder Engine (Gasoline Fuel) |
2.5i Premium (1 style)
Style |
---|
4dr Sdn 2.5i Premium |
Inventory price |
Starting at $23,845 |
Combined MPG |
30 |
Engine |
175.0-hp, 2.5-liter, 4 Cylinder Engine (Gasoline Fuel) |
3.6R Limited (1 style)
Style |
---|
4dr Sdn 3.6R Limited |
Inventory price |
Starting at $29,945 |
Combined MPG |
23 |
Engine |
256.0-hp, 3.6-liter, Flat 6 Cylinder Engine (Gasoline Fuel) |
*Estimated payments are calculated by Cars.com and are for informational purposes only. We’ve estimated your taxes based on your provided ZIP code. These estimates do not include title, registration fees, lien fees, or any other fees that may be imposed by a governmental agency in connection with the sale and financing of the vehicle. Other taxes may apply. They do not represent a financing offer or a guarantee of credit from the seller. Actual terms vary by lender.
Research the 2016 Subaru Legacy
Compare the 2016 Subaru Legacy
- ${price_badge()}
- ${battery_badge()}${ev_report_link()}
- ${hot_car_badge()}
- ${award_badge()}
- ${cpo_badge()}
${price_badge_description}
The EV Battery Rating is based on this vehicle's current expected range relative to the vehicles expected range when new. ${battery_badge_text}
Certified cars are manufacturer warrantied and typically go through a rigorous multi-point inspection.
This car is likely to sell soon based on the price, features, and condition.
${award_blurb}
${award_two_blurb}