Skip to main content

2011
Ferrari 458 Italia

Starts at:
$225,325
Shop options
New 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia
See ratings
Consumer rating
Owner reviewed vehicle score
Not rated
Safety rating
NHTSA tested vehicle score
Consumer rating
Owner reviewed vehicle score
Not rated
Safety rating
NHTSA tested vehicle score
Shop Cars.com
Browse cars & save your favorites
Dealers near you
Find & contact a dealership near you
Listings near 43272
Change location See all listings

Photo & video gallery

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia

The good & the bad

This vehicle doesn't have any good or bad insights yet.

Use our comparison tool to look at this model side-by-side with other vehicles or view the full specifications list .

Start your comparison

Expert 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia review

our expert's take
Our expert's take
By Clifford Atiyeh
Full article
our expert's take


I’m lounging in the back of a Lincoln Town Car as my driver crosses the Golden Gate Bridge, en route to take delivery of a yellow 458 Italia at Ferrari of San Francisco. Granted, it’s got a few thousand miles and is mine for only 24 hours, but I feel like a customer nonetheless.

The Ferrari experience goes like this: Wait two to three years for a new one, or pay well above sticker and drive away with a lightly used one. Unlike Chevy and Porsche franchises, a Ferrari dealer never keeps new cars. They’re all built to order, and the production runs are so limited that more money isn’t often a persuasion to cut the line — you’ve got to own one first to join the club.

With a $1 million Enzo in the showroom and a flock of Maseratis outside, this is quite the used car lot. I’m driving the same car I read about on the cover of Road & Track during the flight from Boston, so I know this model won’t have navigation. Papers signed, I drop my luggage into the crevice of a trunk, stick a Garmin to the windshield, and I’m off. Gosh, that was easy.

Truth be told, this test took two months to negotiate. But one full-throttle explosion through the Waldo tunnel justifies every hurdle — driving a 458 is worth trading in your afterlife. Everything Ferrari has learned from decades of Formula 1 racing is here: a covered underbody with a rear diffuser, flexible front air intakes that provide downforce at high speed, and a squared-off, carbon fiber steering wheel with an LED rev counter.

Inside, Alcantara and buttery Italian leather cover every surface, save for the rhomboid air vents, which protrude in carbon fiber at odd angles from the yellow-stitched dash. A yellow-faced tachometer is the only physical gauge, the speedometer reduced to a small readout in one of two LCD screens. Look for yourself, officer, I didn’t see how fast I was going!

Along mountain passes and coastal highways, the 458 is a tarmac scalpel. My Bay Area friend says he’s never seen so many drivers pull over to let us pass, but he drives a Prius and our bright yellow Ferrari is shrieking harder than a Californian earthquake. There’s as much grip as the 911, only the 458 reacts in neurons. Its balanced, mid-engine layout trumps the tail-heavy Turbo and front-biased Corvette.

Steering is instantaneous and incredibly responsive — scratching an itch can point you into a tree. Slide it a little and the Ferrari hangs on with greater finesse than the mighty all-wheel-drive Porsche. The crisp 7-speed dual-clutch gearbox and the “bumpy roads” option on the magnetic shocks are perfection.

For any amount of money, a Ferrari 458 is the supercar to have. But with its frequent service schedule — and the oft-chance you might ignite, as was the case in a September recall — tuck that Chevy in the garage for good measure.

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia review: Our expert's take
By Clifford Atiyeh


I’m lounging in the back of a Lincoln Town Car as my driver crosses the Golden Gate Bridge, en route to take delivery of a yellow 458 Italia at Ferrari of San Francisco. Granted, it’s got a few thousand miles and is mine for only 24 hours, but I feel like a customer nonetheless.

The Ferrari experience goes like this: Wait two to three years for a new one, or pay well above sticker and drive away with a lightly used one. Unlike Chevy and Porsche franchises, a Ferrari dealer never keeps new cars. They’re all built to order, and the production runs are so limited that more money isn’t often a persuasion to cut the line — you’ve got to own one first to join the club.

With a $1 million Enzo in the showroom and a flock of Maseratis outside, this is quite the used car lot. I’m driving the same car I read about on the cover of Road & Track during the flight from Boston, so I know this model won’t have navigation. Papers signed, I drop my luggage into the crevice of a trunk, stick a Garmin to the windshield, and I’m off. Gosh, that was easy.

Truth be told, this test took two months to negotiate. But one full-throttle explosion through the Waldo tunnel justifies every hurdle — driving a 458 is worth trading in your afterlife. Everything Ferrari has learned from decades of Formula 1 racing is here: a covered underbody with a rear diffuser, flexible front air intakes that provide downforce at high speed, and a squared-off, carbon fiber steering wheel with an LED rev counter.

Inside, Alcantara and buttery Italian leather cover every surface, save for the rhomboid air vents, which protrude in carbon fiber at odd angles from the yellow-stitched dash. A yellow-faced tachometer is the only physical gauge, the speedometer reduced to a small readout in one of two LCD screens. Look for yourself, officer, I didn’t see how fast I was going!

Along mountain passes and coastal highways, the 458 is a tarmac scalpel. My Bay Area friend says he’s never seen so many drivers pull over to let us pass, but he drives a Prius and our bright yellow Ferrari is shrieking harder than a Californian earthquake. There’s as much grip as the 911, only the 458 reacts in neurons. Its balanced, mid-engine layout trumps the tail-heavy Turbo and front-biased Corvette.

Steering is instantaneous and incredibly responsive — scratching an itch can point you into a tree. Slide it a little and the Ferrari hangs on with greater finesse than the mighty all-wheel-drive Porsche. The crisp 7-speed dual-clutch gearbox and the “bumpy roads” option on the magnetic shocks are perfection.

For any amount of money, a Ferrari 458 is the supercar to have. But with its frequent service schedule — and the oft-chance you might ignite, as was the case in a September recall — tuck that Chevy in the garage for good measure.

Available cars near you

Factory warranties

New car program benefits

Basic
2 years
Corrosion
2 years
Powertrain
2 years

Certified Pre-Owned program benefits

Age / mileage
Registered within the past 14 years
Basic
24 months
Dealer certification
101-point inspection

Consumer reviews

5.0 / 5
Based on 4 reviews
Write a review
Comfort 4.3
Interior 4.3
Performance 5.0
Value 4.8
Exterior 5.0
Reliability 3.7

Most recent

Perfect

This car was absolutely amazing, excellent condition, and well maintained. Owner was polite and very knowledgeable, answered every question I had. Very professional.
  • Purchased a Used car
  • Does recommend this car
Comfort 5.0
Interior 5.0
Performance 5.0
Value 5.0
Exterior 5.0
0 people out of 1 found this review helpful. Did you?
Yes No

Exemplary.

Performance. Beauty. Sound. This is the perfect car if you're someone who likes any of those. Ferrari nailed this one.
  • Purchased a Used car
  • Used for Having fun
  • Does recommend this car
Comfort 4.0
Interior 5.0
Performance 5.0
Value 5.0
Exterior 5.0
Reliability 3.0
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful. Did you?
Yes No

Latest news from cars.com

See all news

FAQ

What trim levels are available for the 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia?

The 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia is available in 1 trim level:

  • (1 style)

What is the MPG of the 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia?

The 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia offers up to 12 MPG in city driving and 18 MPG on the highway. These figures are based on EPA mileage ratings and are for comparison purposes only. The actual mileage will vary depending on vehicle options, trim level, driving conditions, driving habits, vehicle maintenance, and other factors.

Is the 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia reliable?

The 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia has an average reliability rating of 3.7 out of 5 according to cars.com consumers. Find real-world reliability insights within consumer reviews from 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia owners.

Is the 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia a good Coupe?

Below are the cars.com consumers ratings for the 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia. 100.0% of drivers recommend this vehicle.

5.0 / 5
Based on 4 reviews
  • Comfort: 4.3
  • Interior: 4.3
  • Performance: 5.0
  • Value: 4.8
  • Exterior: 5.0
  • Reliability: 3.7

Ferrari 458 Italia history

Your list was successfully saved.
Your comparisons
 
 
 
 
Save list Compare