Atlantic Toyota

(2,316 reviews)
207 Sunrise Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795
Visit Atlantic Toyota
Sales hours: 9:00am to 9:00pm
Service hours: 7:00am to 7:00pm
View all hours
Sales Service
Monday 9:00am–9:00pm 7:00am–7:00pm
Tuesday 9:00am–9:00pm 7:00am–7:00pm
Wednesday 9:00am–9:00pm 7:00am–7:00pm
Thursday 9:00am–9:00pm 7:00am–7:00pm
Friday 9:00am–9:00pm 7:00am–7:00pm
Saturday 9:00am–6:00pm 7:00am–5:00pm
Sunday 11:00am–5:00pm Closed
2022 consumer dealer award
View 5 awards
2022 consumer dealer award 2019 consumer dealer award 2017 consumer dealer award 2016 consumer dealer award 2015 consumer dealer award

Contact seller

Select a Salesperson (optional)

Contact seller

By clicking here, you authorize Cars.com and its sellers/partners to contact you by text/calls which may include marketing and be by autodialer. Calls may be prerecorded. You also agree to our Privacy Notice. Consent is not required to purchase goods/services.

We value your privacy. Cars.com Privacy Notice

New (877) 634-2418 (877) 634-2418
Used (877) 644-3382 (877) 644-3382
Service (877) 216-0460 (877) 216-0460

Inventory

See all 133 vehicles from this dealership.

About our dealership

Every vehicle purchases from our dealership comes with one year of free maintenance including three oil and filter changes a 19-point fluid and visual inspection interior fabric and exterior paint protection 24-hour roadside assistance and much more.
Atlantic Toyota...Moving Forward !

Photos & Videos

Service center

Phone number (877) 216-0460

Service hours

Monday
7:00am–7:00pm
Tuesday
7:00am–7:00pm
Wednesday
7:00am–7:00pm
Thursday
7:00am–7:00pm
Friday
7:00am–7:00pm
Saturday
7:00am–5:00pm
Sunday
Closed
See all service & repair info

Meet our employees

Mike Keehner headshot
Mike Keehner
Service Advisor
(155 reviews) certified badge
William Blackwood headshot
William Blackwood
Sales Manager
(148 reviews) certified badge
Nick Frank headshot
Nick Frank
Service Director
(21 reviews) certified badge
Greg Connelly headshot
Greg Connelly
Sales Consultant
(55 reviews)
Jason Javier Membreno headshot
Jason Javier Membreno
Sales Consultant
(38 reviews)
Lynn Vanegas headshot
Lynn Vanegas
SALES CONSULTANT
(32 reviews)
Lorenzo Pierre-Louis headshot
Lorenzo Pierre-Louis
Sales Consultant
(22 reviews)
Angel Marroquin headshot
Angel Marroquin
sales consultant
(21 reviews)
Tim Keehner headshot
Tim Keehner
Service Manager
(120 reviews)
Rich Healy headshot
Rich Healy
General Sales Manager
(42 reviews)
Nelson Pacheco headshot
Nelson Pacheco
Product Specialist
(42 reviews)
Jasmine Farraj headshot
Jasmine Farraj
Sales Consultant
(15 reviews)
Darien Barnes headshot
Darien Barnes
Sales Consultant
(36 reviews)
Frank Musmacker headshot
Frank Musmacker
Service Advisor
(31 reviews)
LJ Cafarelli headshot
LJ Cafarelli
Sales Consultant
(22 reviews)
Luis Celin headshot
Luis Celin
Sales Consultant
(11 reviews)
Liz Needham headshot
Liz Needham
Sales Consultant
(20 reviews)
Sandra Dellolio headshot
Sandra Dellolio
BDC Manager
(11 reviews)
Stephen Torrens headshot
Stephen Torrens
Sales Manager
(3 reviews)

Reviews

(2,316 reviews)

A dealership's rating is based on all of their reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews. Includes reviews of Atlantic Toyota from DealerRater.

Want to share your experience with this dealership?

Write a review

William was extremely helpful and personable.

September 18, 2025
By chenits on DealerRater

Verified Customer

William was extremely helpful and personable. It was a wonderful to have him guide me through a nerve racking experience. Thank you, Will

William was extremely helpful and personable.

September 18, 2025
By chenits on DealerRater

Verified Customer

William was extremely helpful and personable. It was a wonderful to have him guide me through a nerve racking experience. Thank you, Will

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service —
  • Buying process —
  • Quality of repair —
  • Overall facilities —
  • Overall experience 5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Shopped for a new car
Worked with:
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Show full review

Great service!

September 18, 2025
By cms2rjs2 on DealerRater

Verified Customer

Great service! Mike the rep was super friendly. Everyone should have the customer service skills he has.

Great service!

September 18, 2025
By cms2rjs2 on DealerRater

Verified Customer

Great service! Mike the rep was super friendly. Everyone should have the customer service skills he has.

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service —
  • Buying process —
  • Quality of repair —
  • Overall facilities —
  • Overall experience 5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Came in for service or repair
Worked with:
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Show full review

Everything was excellent.

September 17, 2025
By LARRYLUV626 on DealerRater

Verified Customer

Everything was excellent. I was in and out pretty quick. In about an hour. Mike Keehner is the best.

Everything was excellent.

September 17, 2025
By LARRYLUV626 on DealerRater

Verified Customer

Everything was excellent. I was in and out pretty quick. In about an hour. Mike Keehner is the best.

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service —
  • Buying process —
  • Quality of repair —
  • Overall facilities —
  • Overall experience 5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Came in for service or repair
Worked with:
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Show full review

Great facility, great staff, very helpful .

September 15, 2025
By davebarry on DealerRater

Verified Customer

Great facility, great staff, very helpful . Good coffee. Quick response. Would use again. Thank you

Great facility, great staff, very helpful .

September 15, 2025
By davebarry on DealerRater

Verified Customer

Great facility, great staff, very helpful . Good coffee. Quick response. Would use again. Thank you

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service —
  • Buying process —
  • Quality of repair —
  • Overall facilities —
  • Overall experience 5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Came in for service or repair
Worked with:
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Show full review

The overall experience was great!

September 15, 2025
By amy_brink on DealerRater

Verified Customer

The overall experience was great! Friendly, efficient and helpful staff. It was nice to get the call to set up the appointment.

The overall experience was great!

September 15, 2025
By amy_brink on DealerRater

Verified Customer

The overall experience was great! Friendly, efficient and helpful staff. It was nice to get the call to set up the appointment.

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service —
  • Buying process —
  • Quality of repair —
  • Overall facilities —
  • Overall experience 5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Came in for service or repair
Worked with:
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Show full review

Tasha always makes sure my services always goes smooth

September 14, 2025
By Jennifer Lee on DealerRater

Verified Customer

Tasha always makes sure my services always goes smooth she is an asset to this company

Tasha always makes sure my services always goes smooth

September 14, 2025
By Jennifer Lee on DealerRater

Verified Customer

Tasha always makes sure my services always goes smooth she is an asset to this company

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service —
  • Buying process —
  • Quality of repair —
  • Overall facilities —
  • Overall experience 5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Came in for service or repair
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Show full review

I always have a good experience at this dealership.

September 11, 2025
By davidobrien4321 on DealerRater

Verified Customer

I always have a good experience at this dealership. Tasha is very attentive and knowledgeable.

I always have a good experience at this dealership.

September 11, 2025
By davidobrien4321 on DealerRater

Verified Customer

I always have a good experience at this dealership. Tasha is very attentive and knowledgeable.

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service —
  • Buying process —
  • Quality of repair —
  • Overall facilities —
  • Overall experience 5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Came in for service or repair
Worked with:
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Show full review

Very good experience at this dealership-everyone was

September 11, 2025
By mvis1 on DealerRater

Verified Customer

Very good experience at this dealership-everyone was friendly and helpful! Waiting Lounge was comfortable.

Very good experience at this dealership-everyone was

September 11, 2025
By mvis1 on DealerRater

Verified Customer

Very good experience at this dealership-everyone was friendly and helpful! Waiting Lounge was comfortable.

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service —
  • Buying process —
  • Quality of repair —
  • Overall facilities —
  • Overall experience 5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Came in for service or repair
Worked with:
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Show full review

Bien no tengo ningun comentario negativo me fue muy bien

September 10, 2025
By SANDYSOTO68 on DealerRater

Verified Customer

Bien no tengo ningun comentario negativo me fue muy bien kile buen trabajo good good

Bien no tengo ningun comentario negativo me fue muy bien

September 10, 2025
By SANDYSOTO68 on DealerRater

Verified Customer

Bien no tengo ningun comentario negativo me fue muy bien kile buen trabajo good good

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service —
  • Buying process —
  • Quality of repair —
  • Overall facilities —
  • Overall experience 5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Came in for service or repair
Worked with:
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Show full review

Great service!

September 9, 2025
By DICE383 on DealerRater

Verified Customer

Great service!. In and out service taking care of every issue in a timely manner. Highly recommend the amazing service team.

Great service!

September 9, 2025
By DICE383 on DealerRater

Verified Customer

Great service!. In and out service taking care of every issue in a timely manner. Highly recommend the amazing service team.

Rating breakdown (out of 5):
  • Customer service —
  • Buying process —
  • Quality of repair —
  • Overall facilities —
  • Overall experience 5.0
  • Does recommend this dealer
  • Came in for service or repair
Worked with:
0 people out of 0 found this review helpful.
Show full review
See all 2316 reviews